Manchester Refugee Support Network (MRSN) is deeply concerned by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s announcement of proposed changes to Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR), introducing an ‘earned settlement’ system that could force thousands of people to wait decades before securing permanent status in the UK.
Under the proposals, the standard route to settlement would increase from five to ten years, with significantly longer waiting periods for people who have experienced immigration breaches, relied on public funds, or sought asylum in the UK.
Meanwhile, higher earners would be offered faster routes to settlement. Those earning over £50,000, alongside certain healthcare and education professionals, could qualify after five years, while those earning over £125,000 and people on certain high-talent schemes could qualify after just three years.
We fundamentally oppose an immigration system that determines a person’s right to security and stability based on their income, employment status or route of arrival.
These proposals risk creating a deeply unequal system in which wealthier migrants are rewarded with permanent status, while people on lower incomes, those experiencing hardship and some of the most vulnerable people in our communities face prolonged uncertainty.
We are particularly alarmed by the proposed changes affecting refugees. Under the announced framework, refugees arriving through formal resettlement routes would retain a five-year pathway to settlement, while others could face a twenty-year wait, increasing to thirty years for those who entered the UK without permission.
Seeking asylum is a human right. People fleeing war, persecution and violence often have no choice over how they escape danger or reach safety. Penalising refugees for their route of arrival fails to recognise the realities of forced displacement and risks leaving people who have already experienced significant trauma in decades of insecurity.
We are also concerned about proposals that would disadvantage people who have relied on public funds or experienced immigration breaches. Many people face circumstances beyond their control, including exploitation by employers, homelessness, illness, disability, family breakdown and administrative barriers. These circumstances should not become grounds for further punishment or prolonged exclusion from permanent settlement.
The proposals affecting social care workers are particularly troubling. Many migrant care workers have experienced exploitation, including losing their sponsorship through no fault of their own when employers have had their licences revoked. Although transitional arrangements have been outlined, important questions remain about who will qualify and whether workers will be adequately protected.
These proposals also raise serious questions about their economic consequences and the additional costs they could impose on public services and the voluntary sector.
Extending settlement routes could push more people into poverty, destitution and homelessness by prolonging restrictions on access to public funds, increasing immigration-related costs and making it harder for people to establish stable lives. Rather than supporting economic independence, these measures risk creating further barriers to employment, housing and integration.
Longer routes to settlement would also mean more visa renewals, applications and administrative processes for the Home Office to manage, potentially increasing costs to the taxpayer. At a time when the immigration system is already under significant pressure, it is difficult to see how creating decades-long pathways to settlement represents an efficient or sustainable use of public resources.
Meanwhile, charities like MRSN would be left to pick up the pieces. We already see first-hand the consequences of immigration insecurity, including homelessness, destitution, exploitation and deteriorating mental health. These proposals risk increasing demand for emergency accommodation, crisis intervention, immigration advice and other essential support, placing further pressure on charities and community organisations that are already operating with extremely limited resources.
Rather than reducing costs, these changes risk shifting the financial and human burden onto local authorities, public services and charities, while leaving vulnerable individuals to bear the greatest consequences.
At MRSN, we see first-hand the devastating impact that immigration insecurity has on individuals and families. People who have lived, worked, raised children and contributed to their communities in the UK deserve the opportunity to build stable lives without the constant fear of losing their status.
Extending settlement routes to ten, twenty or thirty years risks increasing poverty, worsening mental health, creating further barriers to integration and leaving people vulnerable to exploitation. The longer people are kept in precarious circumstances, the harder it becomes for them to build financially independent, stable lives and contribute fully to their communities.
Settlement should not be a privilege reserved for the wealthy. Safety, dignity and belonging should not have a price tag.
As an organisation led by people with lived experience of migration and displacement, MRSN calls on the Government to reconsider these proposals, meaningfully consult affected communities and publish a comprehensive assessment of their economic and social consequences, including the potential costs to public services, local authorities and the voluntary sector.
We stand in solidarity with all refugees and migrants whose futures are being placed in uncertainty by these announcements. People who have made the UK their home deserve security, dignity and the opportunity to thrive, not decades of precarious immigration status.