Manchester Refugee Support Network (MRSN) is deeply concerned by the package of reforms to the UK asylum system recently announced by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood. While we recognise the Government’s desire to manage migration, we believe these changes risk inflicting serious harm — both to people seeking safety and to the very organisations, like ours, that support them.
Our key concerns are as follows:
- Temporary Refugee Status and Frequent Reviews
The proposal to end permanent refugee status and require individuals to re-apply for protection every 2.5 years is deeply troubling. Such recurring uncertainty will destabilise the lives of people who have already fled trauma, making it harder for them to rebuild, integrate, or plan long-term. - Extremely Long Path to Permanent Settlement
Under the proposals, those who entered the UK illegally or overstayed a previous entry Visa could have to wait up to 20 years before applying for permanent settlement. This is a punitive timescale that risks consigning people to decades of limbo. Uncertainty on this scale prevents many from establishing stable lives, accessing education or employment securely, or contributing fully to their communities. - Discretionary Support
The Government is proposing that housing and financial support for asylum seekers become discretionary, rather than guaranteed. We fear that this change will leave many vulnerable people — including those who cannot work yet due to legal or practical barriers — without the vital support they need. It also massively increases the risk of destitution, homelessness, and mental health harm. - Narrowing Article 8 Human Rights
The plans to restrict the interpretation of human rights protections (notably Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights) to only include immediate relatives will devastate refugee and migrant families. Family separation can have profoundly traumatic effects, and these reforms would disproportionately penalise those already most vulnerable. - Use of AI for Age Assessment
The proposed use of artificial intelligence to assess the ages of asylum applicants is highly problematic. The risk of racial bias or error in such systems is real, and misclassification could lead to minors being treated as adults — with all the safeguarding failures and heightened vulnerability that would entail. - Pressure on Civil-Society Organisations
As a network that provides vital services to refugees, MRSN anticipates that these reforms will dramatically increase pressure on our volunteers, staff, and resources. By increasing uncertainty, reducing support, and limiting rights, the changes risk creating a larger need for emergency aid, advocacy, and aftercare — precisely during a period when our ability to meet demand may be stretched to the limit. - Likelihood of Increased Intimidation and Bullying
We are also concerned that these reforms — and the public rhetoric surrounding them — may contribute to a climate in which refugees, asylum seekers, and those who work with them face increased hostility. Heightened uncertainty, coupled with political narratives framing people seeking safety as a “problem,” risks empowering those who wish to intimidate, harass, or subtly bully our clients and staff. These proposals may exacerbate tensions not only for our organisation but for refugee-support charities across the country. - Increased Workload and Strain on the Home Office
The reforms would also generate significant additional administrative burdens for the Home Office at a time when its capacity is already stretched to breaking point. Frequent re-assessments of refugee status, more complex appeals, restrictions on family reunification, and expanded age-dispute processes will require enormous bureaucratic resources. These measures risk creating bottlenecks that slow down decision-making further, prolonging uncertainty for applicants and increasing the workload for civil servants, legal advisors, and frontline support services. A system already struggling with delays should not be encumbered with processes that are likely to make those delays even worse.
Conclusion & Call to Action
Manchester Refugee Support Network urges the Government to reconsider these reforms. Rather than punitive, restrictive measures, we call for policies that:
• protect the dignity, stability, and long-term prospects of refugees;
• ensure predictable and meaningful support for asylum seekers;
• preserve family unity and the human rights of all people seeking safety in the UK;
• safeguard clients, volunteers, and staff from hostility and intimidation;
• respect the role and capacity of civil-society organisations in delivering these services;
• strengthen, rather than overload, the functioning and efficiency of the Home Office.
We remain committed to our mission of supporting refugees and asylum seekers and stand ready to work with policymakers, local authorities, and communities to develop more humane, sustainable, and just reforms.
For more information on how these changes will affect refugees and asylum seekers, head to Greater Manchester Immigration Aid Unit’s blog: https://gmiau.org/nov-25-changes-to-the-uk-asylum-system-what-we-know-so-far/