Substantive interviews are a key part of the asylum process where the Home Office asks detailed questions about your life, your journey and why you cannot safely return to your country. This page gives example questions that people are often asked in these interviews so you can better understand the types of topics and level of detail the interviewer may expect, but it is not legal advice and cannot replace preparation with a qualified adviser or lawyer. Please go to Asylum Support Service for face to face, IAA-accredited advice.
Your lawyer may submit a written statement before the interview. If you are going to be explaining very upsetting events, this might be a useful thing to do, so that you do not have to be asked so many detailed questions about events. Not all lawyers will do this, as some lawyers think it can be risky to submit a statement in advance that the Home Office interviewer can then “test” you on during the interview. A statement may also be submitted after the interview, particularly if there are things you weren’t given a chance to explain or you think there were problems with the interview.
It is your legal right to have the interview audio-recorded.
The Home Office’s internal guidance on asylum interviews suggests that their policy is now to audio-record all interviews unless the person being interviewed requests that it isn’t recorded.
In the past, you had to request audio-recording in writing 24 hours or more in advance of the interview. Although this no longer seems to be Home Office policy, the information on their own website still says – at the time of writing – “You can ask for this interview to be tape recorded if you do not have legal representation. Ask your caseworker at least one day before”. It is therefore probably a good idea to still request audio-recording in writing in advance until automatic recording is standard practice.
If the recording equipment is not working and the interviewer cannot find alternative equipment, they should offer to re-arrange the interview.
Some people find it useful to write down the important points of the story, or draw symbols and pictures, to get it straightened out in their head before they are asked questions in the interview (often in a confrontational way). You will not be able to take these into the interview with you, however.
You may wish to write, or tell a friend who will write it for you, a timeline of the events that took place leading up to you having to leave your country. Discuss this with a friend, and it may prompt memories of important facts or details that you had forgotten.
Are there parts of your story that don’t make sense to them? Is this because there are things you’ve forgotten to say? Or are there things that don’t seem that important to you but are crucial to explaining the story to someone who wasn’t there?
Be prepared, but in your interview try not to sound like you are repeating a script from memory or sound rehearsed, as this may seem like you are not telling the truth.
If you cannot remember a date, say you cannot remember. If you guess a date, and then say a different date at a different point in the interview or a later stage of your application, this will be used to doubt your story. You may not be able to remember an event by a day or month but by the weather, the season or a family occurrence. You can explain these instead if you are sure of them.
Be aware that the person interviewing you may know very little about your country and/or culture. This can lead to misunderstandings in the interview, and ultimately to a refusal of your asylum claim. For example, you may use the word “auntie” or “uncle” to refer to someone you know. In the UK, these words usually have specific meanings – the brother or sister of your mother or father. If you use the word “uncle” in the broader meaning, for example if you said “my uncle in Kabul helped me”, it will cause confusion if you later say you haven’t got any family in Kabul.
You may be re-telling difficult experiences, and remembering these events can be upsetting. It is important, however, to try and give enough detail about the events to explain them to someone who wasn’t there, isn’t from your country, and to explain why these events led to you having to leave your country.
Giving details about a physical or sexual assault can be particularly distressing, but your testimony will be used to make a decision on your asylum claim. It is therefore important to include information such as:
- who attacked you
- what they were wearing
- if they were police or army or secret police (and their rank if you know it)
- what they did to you
- how often it happened, particularly if you were in prison/detention at the time
- who else was present;
- how you managed to survive.
The interview is likely to go on for a few hours, so they can ask hundreds of questions. Discrepancies, omissions, vague or evasive answers, lack of detail, lack of knowledge and lack of explanation all give ammunition to decision makers to refuse a claim on credibility grounds
A basic understanding of the definition of a refugee and the importance of credibility may help to understand the relevance of certain questions.
Be prepared for the interview to feel like an interrogation, the Home Office seem to start from a position of disbelief, not a position of neutrality.
Example questions to start:
- Do you have any medical conditions?
- Have you brought any documents you wish to submit today as part of your asylum claim?
- Are you aware of the contents of your screening interview?
- Are there any mistakes you want to correct from it?
Example Background questions:
- Where did you live in Afghanistan?
- Were you educated?
- What is your religion?
- What family do you have in Afghanistan?
- What is the flag/bordering countries/leader? (Questions to establish he actually is from Afghanistan)
Example Asylum claim questions:
- Who do you fear?
- Why do you fear them?
- Do you fear anyone else?
- Is there anyone you fear in any other country?
- When did your problems first start?
- Was there a specific event which made you leave your country? Was it just one event that made you leave? If you’d been suffering persecution over time, what was it about that final event or threat that made you leave at that point?
- If you didn’t leave your country immediately after an incident that put you or people you know in danger, why was there a delay?
- Has the threat affected other people? Has anyone in your family experienced the same treatment? If someone in your family has been granted asylum in Europe because of it, mention this and give details.
- If your family or other people persecuted in the same way did not leave the area, why didn’t they leave? Why did you leave and they didn’t? If you left family members behind, did you put any measures in place to try and ensure their safety?
- If family members or other people in similar situations to you haven’t been threatened, explain why you have.
- What do you believe would happen if you returned to Afghanistan? – you need to show you are at risk of something happening if you were returned to your country now.
- In your screening interview you said…can you talk more about this?
- Did you sustain any injuries? If so do you have evidence of this?
- If you returned to Afghanistan could you live somewhere different to where you were persecuted?
- Did you travel through any other countries on your way to the UK? If yes, why didn’t you claim asylum there?
- Did you claim asylum straight away when you arrived in the UK? If not, why not?
- If you were imprisoned in your home country as part of your persecution, you will need to explain how you were released, or if you escaped explain how you managed this. The Home Office are usually very suspicious of escape stories – be clear about how this was possible, and don’t assume the Home Office know anything about how these things work in your country.
- Are other people facing longer sentences/torture, and might this happen to you if you were imprisoned again?
- If you were mistreated while you were imprisoned, make sure to give information about this. Were there bad conditions? For example, many people sharing a small cell, withholding of food rations, no “yard” time outside, or were you kept in isolation? Did you experience torture?
At the end of the interview the interviewer should ask four questions:
- Whether you have anything to add
- Whether you have any other reasons for wanting to remain in the UK
- Whether you have understood the questions
- Whether you intend to submit further evidence by any agreed deadline
These questions are more for the Home Office’s benefit than yours – they may be used against you if you later add further information or claim not to have understood a question, etc.
If you have further evidence to submit, you need to identify a ‘reasonable timescale’ in which do it.
At the end of the interview you should receive a digital audio copy of the interview record and a written verbatim record of the interview.
You may be asked to sign an acknowledgement on the written copy or on a proforma. This is not to agree to the accuracy of the contents. You do not have to sign.
At the end of the interview, make sure you are given a copy of the audio recording, as well as a written copy of what was said by you and by the interviewer during the interview. These should be given to you immediately after the interview. Your lawyer will need a copy of these.